The Carrot Underground🥕

  • Recipes
  • Vegan Living
  • Shop
  • About
  • Subscribe
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Vegan Living
  • Shop
  • About
  • Subscribe
    • Bluesky
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Threads
    • YouTube
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Vegan Living
    • Shop
    • About
    • Subscribe
    • Bluesky
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Threads
    • YouTube
  • ×
    Home » Vegan Living

    Why Vegan Butter is Better

    The vegan recipe developer and author Connie Edwards McGaughy in her kitchen.
    Modified: Feb 19, 2026 · Published: Dec 12, 2019 by Connie Edwards McGaughy · This post may contain affiliate links

    What is better than butter? Why, vegan butter of course! Here's everything you need to know about enjoying the creamy goodness of butter while being kind to animals and the environment. How delicious is that?

    A slice of baguette with a pat of homemade vegan butter spread on top.

    When you choose vegan butter over dairy butter, you're not just treating your taste buds - you're also giving animals, the Earth and yourself a big high-five!

    With so many great tasting plant-based butter options in stores today, making the switch is easier than ever. In fact, you can even whip up a batch of your own homemade vegan butter in just a few minutes!

    Table of Contents
    • Why we love butter
    • Dairy butter vs margarine
    • Vegan butter vs margarine
    • How to make homemade vegan butter
    • Comments

    Why we love butter

    Butter. It's one of those everyday basic staples most of us use, but don't give much thought. Few of us would ever consider eating a spoonful of butter on its own, but we also couldn't imagine eating a slice of bread or an ear of corn without it.

    So what is it about butter that we love so much?

    One word: Fat. The fat content in butter enhances flavors and textures, transforming the most bland ingredients into something rich and palatable. That dry piece of toast with a dab of butter suddenly becomes moist, chewy, tastier and easier to eat. It's one of those all-purpose players in the kitchen - we use it for sautéing, baking, basting, browning, and in savories, sweets, and sauces.

    The irony is, the very thing that makes butter great can also be harmful to us when we consume too much. Particularly when the source of the fat is animal-derived.

    Today, a lot of people are turning away from adding butter and oil to foods. Fortunately, it is relatively easy to successfully adapt many recipes without using added oils, such as this recipe for vegan oatmeal muffins or this rich and creamy vegan broccoli soup.

    For those of us who like a dab of butter on a stack of pancakes or as a sauce for dipping artichoke leaves, vegan butter is a much better choice than dairy.

    A vegan stuffed artichoke on aplate with seared tofu and roasted carrots.

    A stuffed artichoke with seared tofu and vegan lemon butter sauce.

    Dairy butter vs margarine

    When my brother and I were kids, our mom realized we were eating way too much animal fat. Worried about the future condition of our young arteries, she decided to ditch butter and switch to margarine, assuming it was a better option. She, like other consumers in the 1960's and 70's, weren't aware that margarine was not much better than dairy butter. They didn't know that the process used to manufacture margarine created a different form of fat, known as 'trans fat'.

    Vegan butter vs margarine

    While both vegan butter and margarine are plant-based alternatives to traditional butter, they differ in their ingredients and processing. Vegan butter is usually made with oils that do not contain hydrogenated fats, which are often present in some margarine varieties.

    During the manufacturing of margarine, hydrogen is added to vegetable oil, causing the oil to harden at room temperature. The resulting 'partially hydrogenated oil', or trans fat, has been shown to negatively affect cholesterol levels, contributing to heart disease, according to this article from the Mayo Clinic.

    Some margarines also contain whey or animal-derived milk products. In contrast, vegan butter is not hydrogenated and doesn't contain milk or other animal products.

    vegan butter recipe farm animal sanctuary

    The author visiting a rescued former dairy cow at Charlie's Acres Farm Animal Sanctuary in Sonoma, California.

    Vegan butter is kinder

    We know that consuming animal-derived dairy products and trans fats are unhealthy and harmful to us. Yet, many of us who care about animals may be unaware of the suffering and trauma endured by dairy cows.

    Who doesn't remember the "happy cows" ad campaigns? Quite to the contrary, those bucolic images of cows grazing in green pastures are propaganda created by the dairy industry, which unfortunately has influenced many consumers to believe that dairy cows enjoy long, comfortable lives.

    The truth is, most dairy cows spend the majority of their short lifetimes indoors at factory farms.

    Their lives consist of routine artificial insemination, giving birth, and producing milk for human consumption - milk that belongs to their calves, not us. Sadly, most newborn calves are taken from their mamas immediately or soon after birth. The stress and grief experienced by the mother cows and their babies is tragic and entirely unnecessary.

    Vegan butter is also kinder to the environment.

    Unlike traditional dairy butter, which relies heavily on resources from factory farming (causing harm to animals and the planet), packaged vegan butter is typically made from plants that require much less water and land.

    How to make homemade vegan butter

    Recently, I had the opportunity to tour Charlie's Acres, a wonderful and inspiring farm animal sanctuary located in beautiful Sonoma, CA.

    During my visit, Programs Manager Kaleigh Rhoads, showed me how to make vegan butter from scratch. I had never attempted to prepare it myself, assuming it was a lot of work. Boy was I wrong. Using only a few simple, healthy ingredients, Kaleigh created a batch of delicious vegan butter in less than 5 minutes.

    I couldn't believe how easy it was. The results were amazing! You can watch how quickly she made the best vegan butter in this video.

    The recipe in this video was inspired by The Homemade Vegan Pantry* written by the award winning vegan chef Miyoko Schinner.

    Dishes with citrus infused vegan butter, including orange maple, chile lime and lemon basil butter.

    Using the recipe in the video, I created this vegan citrus compound butter blended with fresh orange juice, zest and maple syrup. Compound butter adds extra flavor to foods, like my favorite vegan cornbread.

    A  plate with squares of vegan cornbread and butter.

    Vegan Butter FAQ's

    What is vegan butter?

    Vegan butter is a plant-based alternative to traditional butter made from animal-derived sources. It contains no animal products and is suitable for those following a vegan lifestyle or dairy-free diet.

    What are the main ingredients in vegan butter?

    Vegan butter typically contains a blend of plant-based oils* like coconut, soybean, sunflower, or canola oil, water, and emulsifiers. Some brands may also include non-dairy milk, salt, and natural flavors.

    *It is important to note that palm oil is used by some brands in the manufacturing of non-dairy butters. Unfortunately, the demand for palm oil has driven the deforestation of rainforests around the world, destroying the habitats of many already endangered species, including orangutans. As with all plant-based products, please be sure to read labels before purchasing.

    Is vegan butter healthy?

    It may be a healthier option for individuals with dairy allergies or lactose intolerance. However, like any fat source, it should be consumed in moderation as it is still a concentrated source of calories.

    Does vegan butter taste like real butter?

    The flavor of vegan butter has improved so much over the years it can be difficult to tell the difference between dairy and the non-dairy versions. Taste can vary among brands, so it's best to try different options to find the one that suits your preferences.

    Can vegan butter be used in baking?

    Yes! I use it all the time as a substitute for dairy butter in most baking recipes.

    Enjoy the goodness of vegan living!

    A variety of plant-based dairy products including vegan milk, yogurt, cheeses, ice creams, and butter.

    The good news is, you can still enjoy everything you love about the flavor and texture of dairy foods without causing harm or suffering to animals! See my vegan grocery list for many of my favorite vegan and non-dairy products.

    Vegan grocery lists tacked to a pin board.

    More Vegan Living

    • Connie Edwards McGaughy with Jade at Charlie's Acres Farm Animal Sanctuary in Sonoma, California.
      How To Be Vegan
    • Buffet plates arranged with Mediterranean vegetables and cups of gazpacho.
      How to Host Plant-Based Parties Everyone Will Love
    • A collage of vegan dishes including cream of tomato soup, jackfruit street tacos, Bolognese sauce and pasta, and blueberry muffins.
      31 Favorite Veganuary Recipes
    • A Kitchenaid stand mixer on a counter next to mixing bowls, spatulas, and kitchen tools.
      Favorite Vegan Kitchen Essentials

    About Connie Edwards McGaughy

    Connie Edwards McGaughy is a San Diego-based vegan recipe developer, cookbook author, and founder of The Carrot Underground. She began her journey toward plant-based living in 1977 and has spent nearly five decades creating plant-based recipes and inspiring compassionate living.

    Love this site? 💚 Add us as a preferred source on Google ↓

    Add as a preferred source

    Comments

    No Comments

    Leave a Reply🥕 Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    The vegan author Connie Edwards McGaughy inside her kitchen.

    Hi, I'm Connie! I created The Carrot Underground🥕 as your place to find easy & delicious recipes and inspiration for enjoying the goodness of vegan living.

    Learn more about me →

    Love this site? 💚 Add us as a preferred source on Google ↓

    Add as a preferred source

    Shop My Cookbooks

    A 2-for-1 cookbook promo featuring covers of vegan cookbooks by Connie Edwards McGaughy, titles The Carrot Underground Cookbooks -Volume One and Two.

    Perfect for Any Kitchen

    6 assorted printable kitchen conversions charts available to purchase on The Carrot Underground website.

    My #1 Baking Guide

    A promotion for a plant-based ingredient weights and measurement guide depicting 3 pages from the guide including the cover with an old-fashioned kitchen scale with a carrot on the scale.

    Get Your Copy Here!

    The cover and pages to a downloadable vegan grocery list.

    As Seen In

    Logos from media and websites that feature content from the Carrot Underground including CNN, USA Today, HuffPost, allrecipes, Trivet Recipes, finding vegan, IQ Podcasts, AARP, Apartmentguide, foodgawker and feedfeed.

    Popular

    • Two plates arranged with vegan pumpkin muffins, one partially eaten.
      Vegan Maple Pumpkin Muffins
    • Vegan lemon bars dusted with powdered sugar on a plate.
      Classic Lemon Bars
    • A bowl of shredded cabbage, carrots, and sliced green onions next to a jar filled with classic vegan coleslaw dressing.
      Classic Coleslaw
    • A collage of the vegan barbecue dishes including grilled tofu, watermelon cucumber salad, potato salad, fiesta bean salad, chili, grilled veggie skewers, rainbow wraps, and berry crumble.
      BBQ Recipes & Ideas

    Trending

    • A bowl filled with vegan carrot ginger soup garnished with non-dairy plain yogurt, pumpkin seeds and dill.
      Carrot Ginger Soup
    • A bowl with vegan vanilla ice cream topped with homemade strawberry compote sauce.
      Strawberry Compote Sauce
    • A slice of vegan banoffee pie served on a dessert plate.
      Easy Banoffee Pie (vegan)
    • A vegan lemon cake frosted with lemon cream cheese frosting and topped with lemon curd.
      Vegan Lemon Cake with Lemon Curd

    Recipe Roundups

    • A collage of the vegan barbecue dishes including grilled tofu, watermelon cucumber salad, potato salad, fiesta bean salad, chili, grilled veggie skewers, rainbow wraps, and berry crumble.
      BBQ Recipes & Ideas
    • A collage of vegan desserts made with lemons, including cookies, cake, and lemon curd.
      7 Citrusy Lemon Desserts
    • A collage of vegan dessert pies including lemon meringue, apple, pumpkin, and chocolate dream pie.
      Best Dessert Pies & Crusts
    • A collage of vegan savory pie dishes including Gardener's Pie, Veggie Pot Pie with Tofu, Broccoli Cheese Pot Pie, and Texas Tamale Pie.
      Best Vegan Savory Pie Recipes

    The Carrot Underground is a

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    EXPLORE

    About

    Meet Connie

    Get My Books

    Storefront

    As Seen In

    Logos from media and websites that feature content from the Carrot Underground including CNN, USA Today, HuffPost, allrecipes, Trivet Recipes, finding vegan, IQ Podcasts, AARP, Apartmentguide, foodgawker and feedfeed.

    Stay In Touch

    Subscribe

    Buy Me A Coffee

    Work With Me

    Contact Me

    Privacy | Terms | Disclaimer | Accessibility

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate Disclosure

    © 2018–2026 The Carrot Underground®. All Rights Reserved.

    8 shares
    • 1Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Threads
    • Bluesky
    • X
    • LinkedIn
    • Reddit